SPOILERS AHEAD.
I’m an Outer Banks fan against my will. Seriously. I avoided this shit like the PLAGUE for 3 years. I just knew it was another teen show I was bound to get addicted to and now look what happened. At the age of 27, teen shows and books are still my bread and butter. What can I say – who actually wants to grow up?
I’d like to say I was surprised at how much I liked the first season, but I can’t say that. It’s like it was tailor-made for me. It had stereotypes, it had a good soundtrack, badly written dialogue and teens played by adults pushing 30… what more could I ask for? Although I think the first season was genuinely good TV, if not completely insane, as a whole I’d put the show in the “so bad it’s good” category which is absolutely not a criticism – but I’m not going to talk about the show as a whole here. I’m going to talk about the raging dumpster fire that is Season 4.
It’s safe to say, the fun is over. Sure, this season had its moments of cringe and silliness. I’m not going to sit here and say there weren’t parts that had me howling with laughter at how bad they were, but it’s not a joke anymore, it’s SERIOUS. Am I problematic for loving JJ? Am I even more problematic for him being only my favourite over my other favourite, Rafe? That’s for me to think about. I loved JJ, and from the looks of the OBX Subreddit, everyone else did too. I lost interest in John B after the first season (and after I read a blind item about Chase Stokes getting his fake tan everywhere at the Met Gala – you can judge me, I’m a toxic culture vulture), Sarah is for sure adorable, I like Cleo and Pope and sometimes even Kiara! But alas, none possess the undeniable rizz of Rudy Pankow’s JJ.
There’s lots of salacious gossip going on right now about his character’s horrendous death scene in the Season 4 finale – a scene that had me doubled over in tears and gasping for air (yes, I am crazy). People are speculating that this death scene was a result of Rudy Pankow asking to be written off the show due to unspecified “beef” with Madison Bailey (Kiara). This stuff is neither here nor there for me. If it’s true, it’s sad, but it doesn’t really matter. That they killed him off was unbelievable, even worse was how they did it. If Pankow really did ask to be written off, there’s not a lot the writers could do I suppose – it was always going to be a disaster for this show – but perhaps a more thoughtful, less brutal write-off would have upset the fans a little less. I’m no stranger to crying at TV shows, in fact I’m a seasoned crier, but this really was a gut-punch. As many others have said, despite his assholery, JJ was the heart of the show. He had that vulnerable bad-boy quality that all the girls LOVE – without being an actual murderer (looking at you, Rafe).
The show just isn’t fun anymore. It’s not escapism anymore.. it feels a bit too real. The group have no money to speak of, they’re about to become homeless, Pope is a criminal, oh! and Sarah is pregnant. It kind of puts some of my own issues under the microscope. I am also poor and irresponsible. Can’t I just go to a place where my own adult problems aren’t reflected back at me?!? I just want to fantasise for a moment that I’m carefree and hunting for treasure.
I think Outer Banks should have stayed in its lane – it just doesn’t stand up with all this emotional heft. It used to be good old-fashioned fun, teen romance, teen drinking, teens who have a problem with authority, escape scenes, etc. The writing is too bad for most of it to be taken seriously and I really don’t mean that in a bad way – the show was an absolute hoot to watch. Never have I laughed so much at virtually everything that happened in Season 3. It was fun!!!! JJ’s death wasn’t fun, and didn’t make sense narratively. It goes against the whole message of the show, or so I thought. This show is about sticking it to the MAN, and you’re telling me that the character who arguably had it the hardest was killed by said MAN?!? It has alienated a lot of people, including me, but as I said, teen shows are my bread and butter… and who really wants to grow up?
You can watch Outer Banks on Netflix. Watch at your own risk, though. 4 seasons of fun and chaos just died with JJ.
